Council Tax reform: turning agreement into action
There’s no shortage of agreement that Council Tax needs to change, so why hasn’t it happened yet?
This blog was written by Lisa Hough-Stewart, Director of WEAll Scotland.
Scotland’s Council Tax system is outdated and unfair. There’s no shortage of agreement that it needs to change: more than eight in ten respondents to a Scottish Government consultation supported urgent reform, while our own research found 83% of Scots support a system where owners of high-value properties pay more.
So why hasn’t it happened yet?
That question shaped Tax Justice Scotland’s parliamentary reception on 27 October. Hosted by Paul McLennan MSP, the event brought together politicians, campaigners and policy specialists to discuss how to build momentum for change.
With contributions from Sara Cowan of the Scottish Women’s Budget Group, Juan-Pedro Castro from Future Economy Scotland and Patrick Harvie MSP, alongside Mr McLennan and WEAll Scotland’s Lisa Hough-Stewart the discussion explored what a fairer system could look like, how to protect people through the transition, and how to make a compelling public case for reform. Labour’s Carol Mochan MSP also contributed to the discussion, reflecting engagement across political parties and a willingness to work together to make progress.
The cost of standing still
Debates about tax reform often focus on the risks of change, but there’s a cost of standing still too.
Sara drew attention to the disproportionate impact of Council Tax on women, including the gendered nature of Council Tax debt. These pressures compound women’s unpaid caring responsibilities and reliance on public services.”
A fairer system must take account of people’s circumstances and ability to pay, while supporting the services that help people live well. Debt collection must be considered within the wider public service reform agenda.
What should replace Council Tax?
Juan-Pedro made the case for comprehensive reform, including the potential to replace Council Tax and Land and Buildings Transaction Tax with a progressive property tax. Smaller changes, such as a mansion tax, risk leaving fundamental problems unresolved.
Patrick Harvie outlined the Scottish Greens’ preference for land value taxation, but also their willingness to compromise with a residential property tax while asking where agreement could be found between parties with different preferred models. He highlighted the importance of empowering local government through greater control over fiscal decisions.
These are substantial questions: getting the details right matters. Reform needs to consider fairness between households, the revenue available for services, and the powers local authorities need to respond to their communities.
But differences over the final model should not delay progress.
Start the work now
The question is what happens next: which decisions can be made now, who will take responsibility, and how will progress be maintained?
Participants discussed whether updating valuations could provide a starting point for agreement, while wider decisions about a replacement system are developed. Tax Justice Scotland argued that valuation work and legislation for a new tax should move forward in parallel.
The discussion also highlighted the need for better information about land ownership, use and value, alongside the expertise and systems required to deliver reform.
Paul McLennan recognised the importance of building consensus and setting out a clear timetable. Scotland can lay the groundwork before resolving every detail of a new system.
A commitment to reform needs more than agreement in principle. It needs a clear programme of work, political leadership and a timetable for delivery.
Protecting people through change
Any meaningful reform will change what different households pay. Political leaders need to be honest about that, while explaining how the transition can be managed fairly.
Suggestions included low-income protections, phased increases and deferring some liabilities until a property is sold.
Broad averages can conceal significant differences between households, including those with valuable homes but limited incomes.
Recognising those circumstances should help shape a better system.
Making the positive case
A fairer tax system isn’t just about changing who pays what. It’s about what we can make possible when everyone contributes their fair share.
Participants called for a clearer connection between reform and people’s everyday lives: tackling child poverty, supporting care, strengthening local services and investing in places where everyone can thrive.
Paul McLennan MSP committed to pressing the Government to be bold and build consensus, supported building agreement on revaluation, and suggested a further discussion in around three months. Patrick Harvie MSP called for agreement across political parties and a positive public case for tax as investment in communities, people and place. Carol Mochan MSP highlighted potential legislative routes to address debt owed to public bodies, including a possible Member’s Bill or amendments to relevant public service reform legislation.
Tax Justice Scotland will follow up these contributions and continue pressing for a clear vision, a credible timetable and political leadership. Working across parties and with local government, we can turn the shared recognition that Council Tax is unfair into progress towards a fairer system.